I would describe my political view as “progressive”. What does that mean? In general terms it means I believe in climate change and building lots more affordable housing and probably increasing taxes (provided we have accountability for this). Decriminalize all drugs. Defund the police (to a certain extent). There are many more ideas I have but don’t want to get bogged down in those topics. My “left wing, always NDP” friends probably see me as too conservative on some things, while my centre and “right-ish” friends think I’m a left wing anarchist or something.
I have voted for the Green Party (back when a federal vote gave them money), NDP and Liberal, depending on who I thought had a hope of winning my federal or provincial riding. Basically, I’ve voted “anyone but conservative” although it is possible I would vote conservative in some ridings. For example, Michael Chong is more to the left in the conservative party in many respects so I’d like to support his continued presence with them.
I thought I’d put down my thoughts on candidates in our Kitchener Centre riding, just because.
Firstly, most of us believe this election is completely frivolous. Obviously a power grab attempt by Justin which is sad and expensive. But not surprising. I was pretty happy with the way things were going in parliament. The NDP supported most of the Liberal’s legislation and occasionally the other parties got together and took over a committee and made the Liberals pissed about that. It was amusing and brought a slightly higher level of accountability to the process. I had hoped the Liberals might have developed some humility, but that doesn’t seem to have happened. I have often voted Liberal, and like the most progressive parts of their agenda. But I cannot stand to listen to Justin talk (but then I cannot stand to listen to most political folks talk except for Bob Rae, Bill Clinton, Tom Mulcair (remember him?) and a few others).
Basically, the Liberals promised electoral reform, they held a few meetings, saw how complicated it really was and did not get a huge push for one solution and had a majority anyway, so abandoned it! That led to a lot of disappointment though from the beginning I felt it was a 20% probability at best. Anyway, a minority parliament is the closest thing we can get to that ideal of proportional representation, so I was enjoying this one.
The Liberals did: legalize dope, de-politicize the senate, establish a carbon tax and go to court over it against several conservative premiers, ban plastic bags, get us vaccinated to one of the highest rates in the world. And some other stuff.
The debt is enormous. Ouch. But the Liberal’s CERB and other programs saved people from starving or being evicted or, like in the USA, dying. No party is really in favour of knocking down the debt. CBC had an interesting article on this last year on the Sunday Magazine: its point was that a lot of economists feel the debt is no big deal with such low interest rates and decent economy. Basically, it’s complicated.
My take on the candidates. BTW, I do get fairly disgusted by all the people who call politicians “trolls” or “libtards” or other stupid things. I have worked and talked with many politicians and yes, some of them do talk a little too much b.s. But most of them are in that arena to try and make things better and in any election you have 3 or 4 candidates running, spending money, leveraging friendships, working very hard, and only ONE gets elected. So I appreciate all of their dedication.
Raj Saini (Liberal)
Incumbent. My wife and I were home on a 2014 (2015?) weekend and Raj came walking down our street, alone, knocked on our door and asked for our support run for the Liberal party’s nominee in our riding. I thought it was pretty gutsy of him to knock on random doors and be very upfront about who he was and why he was running. He was a successful pharmacist who had supported the Liberals and when I asked him “why” he was running, he said “to give service to the community” that had allowed him to earn a living. Raj also wanted to help defeat Stephen Harper who he really did not like (neither did I!). He was also passionate about a national pharmacare program which has had some uptake, but still is not “a thing”. I generally don’t join political parties, but we liked Raj so signed up and supported him at the nomination where he was running against Tony Maas who was also an excellent candidate. It was actually exciting to see their speeches because they were both articulate and compelling and offered a slightly different emphasis in their ideas. Raj was, apparently, the candidate liked by the riding folks and did win, but very narrowly.
Since then, I’ve seen Raj at a few events and occasionally at the airport since I used to fly to Ottawa a few times a year (in the beforetimes). Most pundits have described him as a “typical backbencher” which perhaps is not fair? He is around, but doesn’t seem to be part of any inner circle. He sits on committees but certainly doesn’t have the profile of someone like Bardish Chagger who represents neighbouring Waterloo and was also elected in 2015. Her background was as an executive assistant to the Liberal MP Andrew Telegdi, a director of special events for the Kitchener-Waterloo Multicultural Centre and then she ran for office. I appreciate Raj’s long history of running an independent business for over 20 years and being part of the local community.
So Raj is a nice guy, but I really don’t like the fact this election was called, and would like the Liberals to retain their minority. So what to do, eh?
Mike Morrice (Green). In the 2019 election, Mike Morrice did something historic. He and his team took the Greens from 3% (in 2015) to 26% which is pretty crazy. In 2015 they raised/spent $1300 and in 2019 it was over $72K. The riding has historically been a battle between Liberals and Conservatives over the years, but the Greens displaced the Stephen Woodworth group (who spent $86K) to take second place.
Morrice certainly has a devoted (fanatical? excited? crawl through glass?) group of volunteers. As soon as the writ was dropped, his signs were on lawns around the riding. In 2008 he founded Sustainable Waterloo Region and in 2013 he founded Green Economy Canada. They both have websites, but I have no idea if either of them actually do much besides publicize good things. He certainly likes to talk. To anyone, anytime. And he will even phone you to chat if you sign up. He stands for all the “right things” like fixing the funding in long term care and of course the “green issues” and his Blog displays nothing except compassionate enlightenment. So why not just “go with Mike”?
Well, there are a few things that give me pause:
–he is running for the Green Party which has been tearing itself in public for the past year. It is strange and brutal, and although many in the party say once the executive members who are stirring up trouble leave, things will be fine again. But on the Canada Land podcasts, and other places, I’ve heard stories of deep seated racism in the party. Yet Mike and his crew never mention that elephant in the room. In fact, it really seems like he’s running as an independant. Which leads to the second issue.
–I’ve talked with Mike and read his blog, and he is totally into how the Green party is “not whipped” so he can have his own opinion about things and represent the riding as he (and we, I guess) want. That is just fine, but I really have to question that because, why have a party anyway? It seems he is running as an independant and uses the fact he can have independent views as a big plus, so why involve the Green Party at all? We have a party system, so I think they should have some discipline around big issues.
–And of course the Green Party (at the Federal level) will never hold any balance of power, or be able to create any legislation. So the main reason to elect a Green member of parliament is to frighten (coerce?) the government in power into adopting green policies so they can win back those seats. Hmmm, not so compelling.
Mary Henein Thorne (CPC)
Mary also ran in the provincial election for the conservatives and lost to the NDP’s Laura Mae Lindo. Mary’s bio states she has lived in the riding for more than four decades working as an entrepreneur and small business owner, was a constituency case manager for MPP Michael Harris (before the party gave him the boot) and was special assistant in the office of Diane Finley, former Minister of Public Works and Government Services under former Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Mary was appointed VP Ontario Trillium Foundation board (from which she is on leave during the campaign).
Wow, so pretty much a total party insider (hack?) perhaps? She takes over the riding from Stephen Woodworth who managed to make Stephen Harper look centrist when he (Harper) had to keep pushing off Woodworth’s anti-abortion legislation.
Anyway, this is not a place where I would ever vote conservative, and Mary helped me confirm that: CBC asked the four major candidates about their vaccination status and the other three said they had been ‘double vaxxed’ but Mary said that was ‘personal’ information that she did not share. Really? OK, see you later.
Beisan Zubi (NDP)
This is Zubi’s first time running and her bio says she “is a social responsibility and equitable communications consultant and small business owner. She’s previously worked in communication roles at Communitech and the Centre for International Governance Innovation”. She also “worked with” Jack Layton.
I have to say that my father was a mechanic who wound up in a partnership running a auto repair and salvage business for years (where I worked on weekends and a couple of summers sweeping floors, rebuilding cylinder heads, washing parts in solvent and doing some mechanical work very slowly). So I appreciate the fact that Raj ran his own small business for so many years and that business is actually named. Zubi and Thorne both stick on “small business owner” and “entrepreneur” to their bio, but no information is given about what that actually means.
It also says Zubi has “been in Waterloo Region for about five years and lives downtown with her dog.” Nice.
In 2019 the NDP received just over 11% of the vote, which was down 5% from the previous election. Zubi is new to the area so it is pretty unlikely she will do much better and will just get the “die hard NDPers” to voter for her.
Summary
Where does that leave us? Or me? I’d like the Liberals to win another minority, perhaps have Justin step down as leader and have Chrystia Freeland step up, since she is already “minister of everything”. But the only candidate in this riding who can challenge Ray is Mike Morrice and I have many reservations about his platform (and the Green party in general).
So there are the issues as I see them. Decision is, so far, unresolved.
Ted